JOC | CSX’s Intermodal Overhaul Holds Promise for Shippers

10.22.17 | Mark Szakonyi, Executive Editor,

CSX Transportation’s overhaul of its network, which caused disruptions to international and domestic intermodal services, and the trimming of some of those services to Columbus, Ohio, and Detroit, ultimately may benefit shippers. It is too soon to tell, but CSX CEO E. Hunter Harrison plans to present his vision at an investors’ meeting in late October. CSX told investors on Oct. 17 that it is confident it will win back volume that migrated to trucks and rival Norfolk Southern Railway.

“Theoretically, intermodal service will get more reliable and faster since [CSX] won’t have to wait to build density, although those railcars are going to have to be switched somewhere,” said Larry Gross, a senior transportation analyst at FTR Associates. On the potential downgrading of the North Baltimore hump, Gross said he wouldn’t be surprised because “Harrison hates hump yards and [the facility] is an intermodal hump yard using cranes instead of hump.” Block-swapping to create density is cheaper, he said.

The CSX Harrison leaves also may be better positioned to improve intermodal offerings. His successor at Canadian National Railway, Claude Mongeau, made the railroad a dynamo, and, more recently, Harrison’s successor at Canadian Pacific Railway, Keith Creel, is working to do the same, said John Larkin, who heads the transportation practice at investment bank Stifel.

CP has introduced two new international intermodal services since mid-August. “Once everyone Hunterizes their operations, what does one do for an encore? The answer is: offer new services, help your customers grow their markets, and improve transit time consistency, as measured by customers,” Larkin said.

Some of the operations Harrison has closed should have been done years ago, an intermodal analyst told The Journal of Commerce on condition of anonymity. The railroad’s challenge is keeping costs down while making sure there is enough capacity for intermodal surges. Railroads “have traditionally built the church for Easter Sunday, thinking Easter Sunday would be every day of the year,” when most days are akin to a weekday mass, he said.

The analyst suspects Harrison will try to implement day-of-week pricing to even-out intermodal flows, much like the airlines have done for the passenger business. Friday gate reservations would be the most expensive because that is the busiest day, whereas Monday reservations would be cheaper because demand is much lower.

Read the full article by clicking here >

For more information about the work of FTR, follow on Twitter @ftrintel, sign up to receive the State of Freight TODAY monthly eNewsletter, or call Helen Lile at (888) 988-1699, ext. 1.